Latest
World

The treatment of So You Are was disgusting. It also broke no rules

The gruesome discovery of the Melbourne Cup runner’s carcass in a Sydney skip bin wasn’t a case of the system breaking down. To a large extent, it IS the system – and that has to change.

News Line International Staff20 November 2026 at 00:30 UTC1 min read
The treatment of So You Are was disgusting. It also broke no rules

You’d assume this was an awful one-off. But apparently, it is an established procedure. Racing NSW points out, correctly, that government guidance actually prefers the tip. This wasn’t the system breaking down. To an exceptionally large extent, this IS the system.

As you’d expect, the vet clinic has apologised profusely, stated it didn’t conduct the burial, and sacked its contractor. Which all sounds terribly adult, until you realise what’s missing. In its own statement, the clinic said So You Are “was in our care”. Indeed. He died in its operating theatre, and it was the clinic that determined who would dispose of him. It now says it should’ve known how horses are handled after they leave its hospital, and didn’t. No shit.

Most owners and trainers, I suspect, have always assumed that when a horse is put down at a clinic, the clinic buries it. And why wouldn’t they? The clinic no doubt charges for the service. And that’s rather the point. You can outsource the dump truck, but not the duty of care. Fingering a subcontractor, however sorrowfully it’s done, is a monumental cop-out.

Then there is Racing NSW which, to be fair, has earned a fair hearing on welfare. It funds some retraining and rehoming, and since 2017 its rules have banned NSW racehorses from the knackery.

More in World

All World »